评孙隆基《中国文化的深层结构》

本文对孙隆基先生<中国文化的深层结构>作了新的评价.文章认为,我国学术界对孙先生这一著作的评价都有一定的合理性.但是,从另一角度,我们可以看到孙先生这一著作还存在以下六个方面的问题:第一,孙先生的"结构说"并不妥当;第二,研究方法也不科学;第三,研究的目的也是比较渺小的;第四,孙先生作为历史学家,还没有认识到存在主义违背自然之道的不现实之处,对西方的结构主义也没有深入的认识;第五,孙先生对"人欲"和"仁"的理解也不准确;第六,孙先生"确立自我"的主张也有相当的局限性.因此,孙先生并没有真正揭示中国文化的深层结构,他的观点其实是不能成立的.从图书馆学的角度看,本文还可以为高校在读学生提供一种阅读思路.

Review:Sun Longji''s Deeper Structure of the Chinese Culture

The thesis makes some new comments on Sun Longji's Deeper Structure of the Chinese Culture. The comments on and evaluation of Sun's work by the academia are to a certain degree reasonable. However,Sun's work still has the following six defects from a different angle:1. Sun's "structurism" is not appropriate; 2. the research approach is not scientific enough; 3. the aim of the research is comparatively too chickenshit; 4. being a historian,Mr. Sun lacks a deeper understanding of the structuralism in the west...