《黄香故里考辨》之考辨--与张昕先生商榷

云梦出土的“安陆市亭”陶器和载有“安陆”史事的竹简、木牍,都证实了魏晋以前“安陆”城就是今日云梦城。郦道元的《水经注》所述的“郧城”其地形地貌,与今安陆城不对号,靠不住;而杜预所言云梦城,得到我国当代著名的历史地理学家谭其骧先生的充分肯定,他在地图上标示:郧城即云梦城。近代安陆境内传闻的某些碑祠不能证明黄香故里在今安陆。

Textual Criticism of Textual Research on Huang Xiang''''s Native Place:Discussing with Mr. Zhang Xin

The pottery,bamboo slips and inscribed wooden tablets unearthed from Yunmeng testified that the Anlu Town before Wei and Jin Dynasty was the present Yunmeng Town,and this was confirmed by Chinese cultural relic atlas.The topography and geomorphology of Yun Town mentioned by Li Daoyuan in Shui Jin Zhu were not in accordence with that of the present Anlu Town, while the Yunmeng Town mentioned by Du Yu was affirmed by the famous historical geographer Tan Qirang,who marked on the map that the Yun Town was the Yunmeng Town.The tablets and ancestral temples in Anlu city can't prove that Huang Xiang's native place is in the present Anlu city,whereas the Huang Xiang Tomb in Yunmeng county,the tradition of Huang's descendants holding a memorial ceremony for Huang Xiang and the historical administrative regions named after Huang Xiang prove uncontrovertibly that the present Yunmeng county is the native place of Huang Xiang.