Subjectivity and emotion in scientific research |
| |
Authors: | Jeff Kochan |
| |
Affiliation: | Zukuftskolleg/Department of Philosophy, University of Konstanz, 78457 Konstanz, Germany |
| |
Abstract: | A persistent puzzle for philosophers of science is the well-documented appeal made by scientists to their aesthetic emotions in the course of scientific research. Emotions are usually viewed as irremediably subjective, and thus of no epistemological interest. Yet, by denying an epistemic role for scientists’ emotional dispositions, philosophers find themselves in the awkward position of ignoring phenomena which scientists themselves often insist are of importance. This paper suggests a possible solution to this puzzle by challenging the wholesale identification of emotion with subjectivity. The proposed method is a naturalistic and externalist one, calling for empirical investigation into the intersubjective processes by which scientists’ emotional dispositions become refined and attuned to specific objects of attention. The proposal is developed through a critical discussion of Michael Polanyi’s theory of scientific passions, as well as plant geneticist Barbara McClintock’s celebrated “feeling for the organism.” |
| |
Keywords: | Subjectivity Aesthetic emotion Scientific research Intersubjectivity Michael Polanyi Barbara McClintock |
本文献已被 ScienceDirect 等数据库收录! |
|