Virus-induced autoantibody response to a transgenic viral antigen

The induction of autoantibodies and their possible role in the pathogenesis of autoimmune disease are poorly understood. Involvement of infectious agents has been suspected, but direct evidence is sparse. Whether immunological unresponsiveness to self by antibody-forming B cells is maintained by clonal abortion, clonal anergy or suppression, or how the scenario of interactions between helper T cells, B cells and antigen-presenting cells is distorted in autoantibody responses, is being analysed and widely debated. To evaluate tolerance of neutralizing B-cell responses we used transgenic mice expressing the cell membrane associated glycoprotein (G) of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) as self-antigen. We show that autoantibodies to VSV-G cannot be induced by VSV-G in adjuvant or by recombinant vaccinia virus expressing VSV-G, but are triggered by infection with wild-type VSV. The data show that helper T-cell tolerance is crucial in maintenance of B-cell non-reactivity and that cognate T-B recognition is necessary to break tolerance of self-reactive B cells. These results may help to understand mechanisms of virus-induced autoimmunity.     

The T-cell repertoire is heavily influenced by tolerance to polymorphic self-antigens

T cells with V beta 3+ alpha beta receptors are deleted by self-tolerance in mice with particular major histocompatibility complex/self-antigen combinations. This also occurs for other V beta elements. Polymorphism in the major histocompatibility complex and/or the self-antigens that cause massive deletion of T cells using particular V beta elements may be maintained by the need to balance the advantage of a diverse T-cell repertoire against the potential involvement of those elements in autoimmune disease.     

A role for clonal inactivation in T cell tolerance to Mls-1a

Clonal deletion plays a major part in the maintenance of natural self-tolerance in both normal and transgenic mice. Self antigens that are expressed in the thymus result in the physical elimination of autoreactive thymocytes at a particular stage in their development. For example, the majority V beta 6- and V beta 8.1-bearing T cells that recognize the minor lymphocyte-stimulating antigen, Mls-1a (ref. 10) , are clonally deleted in the thymuses of normal mice and transgenic mice expressing Mls-1a (refs 2, 3, 9). In contrast, a very different mechanism of tolerance involving the functional inactivation, but not elimination, of autoreactive cells, termed clonal inactivation or clonal anergy, has been implicated in some experimentally manipulated systems of tolerance. To test further the mechanisms involved in self-tolerance, we have generated transgenic mice expressing a V beta 8.1 beta chain on greater than 95% of peripheral T cells and have tested tolerance to Mls-1a in these mice. Surprisingly, a significant fraction of the CD4+ peripheral cells that survived deletion were non-responsive in vitro to any stimulus tested. Naturally occurring tolerance to a self antigen expressed in the thymus can thus be mediated by clonal anergy, as well as by clonal deletion.     

Expression of anti-DNA immunoglobulin transgenes in non-autoimmune mice

Self-reactive B cells can be regulated by either deletion or inactivation. These manifestations of self-tolerance have been dramatically shown in transgenic mice in which the number of self-reactive cells has been artificially expanded. We have now extended these models to ask if B-cell tolerance as described for non-disease-associated antigens also operates for the targets of autoimmunity. The target we have chosen is DNA. Anti-DNA antibodies are diagnostic of certain autoimmune syndromes in humans and are a characteristic of the murine model of systemic autoimmunity, the MRl/lpr mouse. Antibodies to both single-stranded and double-stranded DNA have been implicated in disease. By generating anti-DNA transgenic mice, we have addressed the question of whether DNA-specific B cells are regulated in normal (non-autoimmune) mice. We indeed found that most transgenic B cells bind DNA, yet we failed to detect secreted anti-DNA. We suggest that as a consequence of their self-reactivity these B cells are developmentally arrested.     

Antibodies to CD3/T-cell receptor complex induce death by apoptosis in immature T cells in thymic cultures

The receptors found on most T lymphocytes bind to antigen presented on major histocompatibility complex proteins and consist of dimers of alpha- and beta-polypeptides associated with the invariant CD3 complex. A fully competent immune system requires a diverse array of T-cell antigen receptors (TCRs) with different specificities. This diversity is generated by rearrangement of TCR alpha- and beta-chain gene segments within the thymus where the receptors are first expressed. Any cells carrying self-reactive receptors must be eliminated, suppressed or inactivated so that destructive autoimmunity is avoided. Recently, compelling evidence has shown that one process involved in producing such self-tolerance is clonal deletion of autoreactive cells within the thymus by an as-yet-undefined mechanism. Here we show that engaging the CD3/TCR complex of immature mouse thymocytes with anti-CD3 antibodies produces DNA degradation and cell death through the endogenous pathway of apoptosis. Activation of this process in immature T cells by the binding of the TCR to self-antigens may therefore be the mechanism which produces clonal deletion and consequently self-tolerance.     

Clonal anergy induced in mature V beta 6+ T lymphocytes on immunizing Mls-1b mice with Mls-1a expressing cells

Tolerance to self-antigens has been shown to develop during ontogeny as a result of the clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells. Tolerance, or better 'nonresponsiveness', to specific antigens can also be induced in adult animals but the mechanism(s) involved are not well understood. Most murine T-helper cells that express the V beta 6 T-cell receptor gene segment are specific for Mls-1a antigens. We have therefore been able to use an anti-V beta 6 monoclonal antibody to follow the fate of Mls-1a specific T cells in adult Mls-1b mice made specifically unresponsive to Mls-1a. We show that the induced unresponsiveness is not due to clonal deletion, but rather to clonal anergy. The anergic V beta 6 T-helper cells express IL-2 receptors and undergo limited blastogenesis in vitro upon stimulation, but do not produce IL-2, in marked contrast to V beta 6 cells from naive mice. Our data appear to represent an in vivo correlate for the induction of anergy that has been observed in T-cell lines in vitro.     

Induction of self-tolerance in mature peripheral B lymphocytes

In transgenic mice, mature peripheral B lymphocytes in lymphoid follicles, like immature B cells, are rendered tolerant by encounter with self-antigen, provided receptor occupancy by self-antigen exceeds a critical threshold. The tolerant state of the B cell is closely correlated with down-regulation of membrane IgM but not IgD antigen-receptors. Identical changes in antigen-receptor expression occur in a subset of follicular B cells in nontransgenic mice, suggesting that clonally silenced self-reactive cells are common in the peripheral B-cell repertoire.     

Tolerance of class I histocompatibility antigens expressed extrathymically

Although convincing evidence has been obtained for the imposition of self-tolerance by the intrathymic deletion of self-reactive T cells, the development of tolerance to antigens which are expressed only in the periphery is not so well understood. We have approached this question by creating transgenic mice which carry a class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene (H-2Kb) linked to the rat insulin promoter. Mice expressing the transgene develop diabetes, but do not appear to mount an immune response against the transgene-expressing pancreatic beta-cells, even when the transgene is allogeneic with respect to the endogenous host H-2 antigens. We have now explored the mechanism of this tolerance further. We find that spleen cells from pre-diabetic transgenic (RIP-Kb) mice do not kill targets bearing H-2Kb, whereas thymus cells from the same mice do. The unresponsiveness of these spleen cells can be reversed in vitro by providing recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2). In older, diabetic mice, responsiveness develops as the pancreatic beta-cells are lost. Our results point to an extrathymic mechanism of tolerance induction, dependent on the continuous presence of antigen and the lack of IL-2 in the local environment of potentially reactive T cells.     

Protein kinase Cdelta controls self-antigen-induced B-cell tolerance

Interaction of a B cell expressing self-specific B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) with an auto-antigen results in either clonal deletion or functional inactivation. Both of these processes lead to B-cell tolerance and are essential for the prevention of auto-immune diseases. Whereas clonal deletion results in the death of developing autoreactive B cells, functional inactivation of self-reactive B lymphocytes leads to complex changes in the phenotype of peripheral B cells, described collectively as anergy. Here we demonstrate that deficiency in protein kinase Cdelta (PKC-delta) prevents B-cell tolerance, and allows maturation and terminal differentiation of self-reactive B cells in the presence of the tolerizing antigen. The importance of PKC-delta in B-cell tolerance is further underscored by the appearance of autoreactive anti-DNA and anti-nuclear antibodies in the serum of PKC-delta-deficient mice. As deficiency of PKC-delta does not affect BCR-mediated B-cell activation in vitro and in vivo, our data suggest a selective and essential role of PKC-delta in tolerogenic, but not immunogenic, B-cell responses.     

Tolerance in T-cell-receptor transgenic mice involves deletion of nonmature CD4+8+ thymocytes

The mechanism of self-tolerance is studied in T-cell-receptor transgenic mice expressing a receptor in many of their T cells for the male (H-Y) antigen in the context of class I H-2Db MHC antigens. Autospecific T cells are deleted in male mice. The deletion affects only transgene-expressing cells with a relatively high surface-density of CD8 molecules, including nonmature CD4+ CD8+ thymocytes, and is not caused by anti-idiotype cells.     

Abnormal differentiation of thymocytes in mice treated with cyclosporin A

Cyclosporin A (CsA) acts as a powerful immunosuppressive agent, and also, when given in repeated doses, can cause T-cell-dependent graft-versus-host disease and organ-specific autoimmune disease in rodents. This suggests that CsA interferes with the processes governing self-tolerance, either by nullifying the activity of T suppressor cells or by preventing the deletion of autoreactive T cells during ontogeny in the thymus. We report here that irradiated mice given repeated injections of CsA show striking dysfunction of the thymus. There are two different effects, the first of which is that CsA seems to block the differentiation of immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes into mature CD4+CD8- and CD4-CD8+ cells expressing a high density of T-cell receptors and CD3 molecules. Second, CsA-treated mice show incomplete deletion of T cells expressing T-cell receptor molecules reactive to self H-2 I-E molecules.     

Programmed death of autoreactive thymocytes

T lymphocytes bearing high-affinity T-cell receptors (TCR) for self-antigens are clonally deleted during thymus development. Several recent studies have identified variable domains of the beta-chain of the TCR that are specifically deleted in vivo in mouse strains that express major histocompatibility complex class II molecules in addition to poorly defined self-antigens, including those encoded by the Mls-1a and Mls-2a loci. Deletion of autoreactive cells in these systems occurs in the thymus, and antibody blocking experiments in vivo have implicated the phenotypically immature CD4+CD8+ 'cortical' subset as the target population for clonal deletion. Similarly, studies with transgenic mice bearing autoreactive TCR have provided independent evidence that clonal deletion occurs at the CD4+CD8+ stage of development. But none of these studies directly identified dying autoreactive cells, and the circumstances leading to deletion remain unclear. Here we report that neonatal thymus contains a significant population of phenotypically mature CD4+CD8- cells bearing autoreactive TCR. When placed in short-term culture, a large proportion (60%) of these autoreactive cells die selectively. Furthermore, their death can be prevented by inhibitors of macromolecule (RNA and protein) synthesis, as is the case for glucocorticoid-induced death of thymocytes. These data indicate that physiological clonal deletion of autoreactive cells involves 'programmed' cell death, and that it can occur in cells with a mature (CD4+CD8-) surface phenotype.     

Depletion of the predominant B-cell population in immunoglobulin mu heavy-chain transgenic mice

The transgenic mouse line M54 was generated by introducing a functionally-rearranged immunoglobulin mu heavy-chain gene into the germ line of a C57B1/6 inbred mouse. Previous examination of the antibodies produced by B-cell hybridomas derived from transgenic M54 mice showed that the presence of the mu transgene grossly altered the immunoglobulin repertoire of unimmunized animals, suggesting that these mice suffer from a serious immunoregulatory perturbation. Studies presented here introduce a new perspective on this functional defect. We show that the lymphoid tissues from these transgenic mice lack virtually all conventional bone-marrow-derived B cells, which constitute the predominant B-cell population in normal mice and which typically produce primary and secondary antibody responses to T-cell-dependent antigens. Moreover, the bone marrow from transgenic M54 mice is depleted of pre-B lymphocytes, indicating a serious defect in early B-cell lymphopoiesis. In contrast, CD5 (Ly-1) B cells, a second B-cell population displaying a characteristic set of cell surface markers which are derived from distinct precursors in the peritoneum, are represented at normal frequencies in these transgenic mice. Thus, the presence of the rearranged immunoglobulin heavy-chain transgene in M54 mice results in an unexpected selective developmental defect that impairs the development of bone-marrow-derived pre-B and B cells without affecting Ly-1 B cells.     

Elimination from peripheral lymphoid tissues of self-reactive B lymphocytes recognizing membrane-bound antigens

The long-standing hypothesis that tolerance to self antigens is mediated by either elimination or functional inactivation (anergy) or self-reactive lymphocytes is now accepted, but little is known about the factors responsible for initiating one process rather than the other. In the B-cell lineage, tolerant self-reactive cells persist in the peripheral lymphoid organs of transgenic mice expressing lysozyme and anti-lysozyme immunoglobulin genes, but are eliminated in similar transgenic mice expressing anti-major histocompatibility complex immunoglobulin genes. By modifying the structure of the lysozyme transgene and the isotype of the anti-lysozyme immunoglobulin genes, we demonstrate here that induction of anergy or deletion is not due to differences in antibody affinity or isotype, but to recognition of monomeric or oligomeric soluble antigen versus highly multivalent membrane-bound antigen. Our findings indicate that the degree of receptor crosslinking can have qualitatively distinct signalling consequences for lymphocyte development.     

Breakdown of self-tolerance in anergic B lymphocytes.

Production of autoantibodies, which characterizes most autoimmune diseases, is normally avoided by active elimination or functional inactivation (anergy) of B and T lymphocytes bearing receptors for self antigens. The mechanisms leading to the escape of self-reactive clones from these normal tolerance mechanisms in autoimmune diseases nevertheless remain obscure. Here, we demonstrate that clonal anergy in B lymphocytes is a reversible process, and that silenced self-reactive B cells can be reactivated under particular conditions to give rise to vigorous antibody responses. Reactivation of anergic lymphocytes may explain many examples of transient autoimmune reactions in normal individuals, and may under pathological conditions be important in the development of chronic autoimmune disease.     

Autoimmune diabetes as a consequence of locally produced interleukin-2.

During cell differentiation in the thymus, self-reactive T cells can be generated. The majority of these seem to be deleted after intrathymic encounter with the relevant autoantigen. As all self antigens are unlikely to be present in the thymus, some autoreactive T cells may escape censorship. Here we study the fate of these cells using transgenic mice expressing the class I molecule H-2Kb (Kb) in the insulin-producing beta-cells of the pancreas. These mice were crossed with mice transgenic for genes encoding a Kb-specific T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) which could be detected using a clonotype-specific monoclonal antibody. Although T cells expressing the highest level of transgenic TCR were deleted intrathymically in double-transgenic mice, Kb-specific T cells were detected in the periphery. These cells caused the rejection of Kb-expressing skin grafts, but ignored islet Kb antigens even after priming. But when double-transgenic mice were crossed with transgenic mice expressing the lymphokine interleukin-2 in the pancreatic beta-cells, there was a rapid onset of diabetes. These results indicate that autoreactive T cells that ignore self antigens may cause autoimmune diabetes when provided with exogenous 'help' in the form of interleukin-2.     

Lower receptor avidity required for thymic clonal deletion than for effector T-cell function.

Clonal deletion in the thymus plays a major part in T-cell tolerance to self antigens. But the mechanism of negative selection, its fine specificity and the threshold of affinity and avidity remains unknown. We have now examined these aspects of negative selection with mice expressing a transgenic T-cell receptor with specificity for lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) glycoprotein in association with the class I H-2Db molecule. These mice were rendered tolerant to LCMV by neonatal infection with mutant LCMVs bearing point mutations in the T-cell epitope recognized by the transgenic T-cell receptor. Variant LCMVs were also tested for their ability to elicit antiviral responses in transgenic mice in vivo and in vitro. Comparison in vivo revealed that a low-avidity receptor interaction, which was unable to induce effector T cells in the periphery, was still sufficient for clonal deletion in the thymus.     

How some T cells escape tolerance induction

A feature common to many animal models of autoimmune disease, for example, experimental allergic encephalomyelitis, experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis and collagen-induced arthritis, is the presence of self-reactive T cells in healthy animals, which are activated to produce disease by immunization with exogenous antigen. It is unclear why these T cells are not deleted during ontogeny in the thymus and, having escaped tolerance induction, why they are not spontaneously activated by self-antigen. To investigate these questions, we have examined an experimental model in which mice are tolerant to an antigen despite the presence of antigen-reactive T cells. We find that the T cells that escape tolerance induction are specific for minor determinants on the antigen. We propose that these T cells evade tolerance induction because some minor determinants are only available in relatively low amounts after in vivo processing of the whole antigen. For the same reason, these T cells are not normally activated but can be stimulated under special circumstances to circumvent tolerance.     

T-cell tolerance by clonal anergy in transgenic mice with nonlymphoid expression of MHC class II I-E

T-cell reactivity to the class II major histocompatibility complex I-E antigen is associated with T-cell antigen receptors containing the V beta gene segments V beta 17a and V beta 5. Mice expressing I-E with the normal tissue distribution (on B cells, macrophages, dendritic cells and thymic epithelium) induce tolerance to self I-E by clonal deletion in the thymus. By contrast, we find that transgenic INS-I-E mice that express I-E on pancreatic beta-cells, but not in the thymus or peripheral lymphoid organs, are tolerant to I-E but have not deleted V beta 5- and V beta 17a-bearing T cells. Moreover, whereas T-cell populations from nontransgenic mice proliferate in response to receptor crosslinking with V beta 5- and V beta 17a-specific antibodies, T cells from INS-I-E mice do not. Thus, our experiments provide direct evidence that T-cell tolerance by clonal paralysis does occur during normal T-cell development in vivo.