真作假时假充真——评叶植先生指白梅习氏“造假”的伪学术实质和反逻辑手法

习凿齿晚年徙居白梅,是"史不及载"的历史真实。叶植先生一再撰文否定,诬指白梅习氏"造伪",却举不出确凿证据,只得借无中生有、引用不实之录和讹误史料、曲解《白梅习氏族谱》及其序文、玩弄种种反逻辑手法以支撑虚假命题。中华民族尊重自己的历史和文化,国有史、方有志、家有谱。家谱是"祖国文化宝藏"。文史研究者理应善待家谱,善待历史,诚实研究,切勿自以为是挑战历史,玩弄历史。

Fallacious would Become True When Truth was Treated as Fallaciousness----Review of Mr. Ye Zhi's Accusation of Baimei Xi Clan's 'False Claim' Based on His Fallacious Academic and Anti--logic Techniques Bai Mei Shi

It is a well recorded historical truth that Xi Zaochi lived in Baimei, Xinyu in his old years. Mr. Ye Zhi keeps on authoring articles to deny this historical truth and accusing the Baimei Xi clan made false claims with no conclusive evidences. He basically relied on false entries and records, misinterpret Xi family genealogy, and playing all kinds of anti--logic techniques to support his false proposition. We chinese respect our own history and culture. We have history record as a nation, county record for local history, and genealogy for family history. Genealogy is ＂the culture treasure of our motherland＂. Literature and history researchers should treat the genealogy and history with respect and honesty. Please do not challenge the history and playing with history.