Sleep disturbance due to transportation noise: ear plugs vs oral drugs

Conclusion Sleep is not only the output of an EEG machine but a global phenomenon with unique physiological, environmental and psychological features occurring in a given individual. There is no question that statistical evaluation of noise-induced sleep disturbances in non homogeneous groups of subjects has resulted in the construction of a magnificent neurophysiological edifice by assembling a few individual bricks. In this respect, whether subjectively disturbed or not, we now know that when we sleep in noisy areas our delta sleep is reduced, our heart rate fails to habituate to individual noises, and we are more likely to develop psychic disturbances than residents in quiet areas. Data from these studies are however interspersed with results from a number of experiments during which the subject has been looked upon as nothing but a sleeper, i.e., experiments in which day-time stresses and noises were considered as irrelevant for the night-time study. It seems important therefore that future studies should gather more longitudinal data based on a limited number of subjects selected according to their day-time habits and psychological (e.g., extroverts/introverts) and physiological (e.g., short or long sleepers) characteristics. The knowledge about these situational factors and personality traits might provide new insights into individual biological strategies developed to cope with noise stress. The difficulties in assessing the effect of noise on sleep are particularly obvious if we consider another finding: deaf subjects spend significantly less time in delta sleep than do control subjects⁴⁷ and they present sleep pattern alterations remarkably similar to those which are most consistently described in noisy conditions.Research by the authors has been supported by grants from the Ministère de la Qualité de la Vie et de l'Environnement (France) and Commission of European Communities.