《明朝那些事儿》与《明史讲义》的比较研究

当年明月的《明朝那些事儿》这部＂三十年来最畅销之史学读本＂与孟森的史学著作《明史讲义》在基本结构,史料选用和史学论点等方面有着某种切合,但不可否认前者相对于后者的细致化、明晰化、生动化的创新。总体来说,相比于《明史讲义》,《明朝那些事儿》一书融入了相当多的时代性元素,并且使用＂心灵分析法＂这一新的研究方法展开叙述,使得历史人物和历史事件更加饱满、立体地呈现出来。

A Comparative Study between Those Stories of Ming Dynasty and Lecture Notes to the History of Ming Dynasty

Those Stories of Ming Dynasty by Dangnian Mingyue,＂the best seller of history books in the last thirty years＂,and the historical work Lecture Notes to the History of Ming Dynasty by Meng Sen correspond with each other to some degree in terms of basic structure,selection of historical data,historical arguments,and so on,but the former is more detailed,clear,and vivid.On the whole,compared with Lecture Notes to the History of Ming Dynasty,Those Stories of Ming Dynasty incorporates many contemporary elements,and draws on the new research method of mental analysis to create the narrative,which makes historical figures and events presented more fully and clearly.