有效论证与好论证的关系

有效论证和好论证都是积极的论证评价,两者既有区别又有联系;从非形式逻辑的视阈看,有效论证是好论证的重要条件;从命题逻辑推演、语义层面和论证图示的角度分析,有效论证既不是好论证的充分条件也不是好论证的必要条件;有效性在形式逻辑和非形式逻辑中有明显的量的差异,从有效论证和好论证的关系可以更好理解形式逻辑和非形式逻辑的关系。

On the Relationship Between a Valid Argument and Good Argument

The Valid argument and the good argument are both positive argument evaluation,which are both different and related; from the perspective of informal logic,the valid argument is an important condition for the good argument; from the perspective of propositional logic deduction,semantic analysis and argument map,the valid argument is neither a sufficient condition nor a necessary condition for the good argument; There are obvious quantitative differences between formal logic and informal logic in validity. We can better understand the relationship between formal logic and informal logic from the relationship between the valid argument and the good argument.