对抗?对话? --实践美学与生命美学本体论之争辨析

生命美学与实践美学论争的焦点集中在本体论问题上。实践美学本体论固有其缺陷，但其功绩亦难以全盘否定；生命美学抓住实践美学难以自圆其说的漏洞后，试图作一次美学理论的全面革新。但将立论基点从实践移到生命这一更具宽泛性和不确定性的范畴上，却只能视其为一次迂回。本认为，这次论争应尽快从对抗走向对话。

Confrontation or Dialogue: Analysis of the Argument about Ontology between Practical Aesthetics and Life Aesthetics

The debate between practical aesthetics and life aesthetics principally concentrates on the sphere of ontology. Practical aesthetics admittedly has it's defects, but it still has the unique value and shouldn't be negated totally. Life aesthetics want to make a comprehensive innovation about the aesthetical theory after it's debate against the shortcomings of practical aesthetics. However ,it just can be looked as a kind of retreat because of the transform of fulcrum of the theory is from practices to life ,which is a more covering and undetermined category than the former. Therefore, the argument between practical aesthetics and life aesthetics ought to change from confrontation into dialogue.