Failure to find holes in the T-cell repertoire

The ability of an animal to respond to a given antigenic peptide depends on its major histocompatibility complex (MHC) type. Some peptides are not immunogenic when combined with a particular form of the MHC-encoded molecule. This non-responsiveness is regulated by immune response (Ir) genes and is thought to arise by one of two distinct mechanisms. Either the MHC-encoded molecules physically fail to interact with the antigen, preventing the activation of T cells with appropriate receptors, or they limit the expressed repertoire of T cell clones so that no T cells are available to be activated by existing complexes of MHC-encoded molecules and antigen. Experimental evidence has been generated to support both mechanisms. However, the relative importance of each has not been clearly established. In this study we started with a peptide that was immunogenic in B10 mice; it was thus known to be able to interact with the MHC molecule, and T cells existed which could recognise the peptide-MHC complex. Based on previous experiments, we then changed only those parts of the peptide that we thought interacted with the T-cell receptor. All the new analogues created were still immunogenic, confirming that the amino-acid substitutions that we had made did not prevent productive interactions with the MHC-encoded molecule. No limitations ('holes') in the T-cell repertoire were found. The experiments demonstrate the vast potential of the T-cell population to recognize many different analogues, each in a unique way, and suggest that constraints on the diversity of the T-cell repertoire may not be a major explanation for Ir gene defects.     

Determinant selection is a macrophage dependent immune response gene function

Immune response (Ir) genes are linked to the species histocompatibility complex and define as yet uncharacterised phenotypic products which control the immune response to thymus dependent antigens. Antibody formation and antigen induced T lymphocyte proliferation are two examples of immune phenomena which, in vivo and in vitro, operate under Ir gene influence. To clarify their mechanism of action and cellular location, we have examined the contribution of antigen structure (amino acid sequence and conformation to Ir gene control of antigen recognition by T lymphocytes) as well as to the critical role played by the antigen presenting macrophage in expression of that control. We report that immune response gene control of antigen recognition operates at least in part at the level of the macrophage.     

Cytotoxic T-cell response to H-Y in 'non-responder' CBA mice

Murine cytotoxic T-cell (Tc cell) responses to various antigens are controlled by immune response genes (Ir) mapping in the major histocompatibility complex (H-2). Both helper T cells, controlled by I region-coded genes, and Tc cells, controlled by K/D antigens, are necessary for a positive response. An H-2-restricted Tc-cell response to the male specific minor transplantation antigen (H-Y) can be elicited in B10 (H-2b) female mice primed with syngeneic male spleen cells intraperitoneally (i.p.) or intravenously (i.v.), or by skin grafting followed by restimulation in vitro in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLR) with male cells. CBA (H-2k) mice do not respond by these routes of in vivo priming, and this was thought to be due to a lack of permissible Ir genes for helper function. However, we now report that subcutaneous hind-footpad (fp) immunisation of 'non-responder' CBA mice with syngeneic male cells changes them to responders, a result which argues against a generalised Ir gene-controlled helper defect.     

A trans-acting class II regulatory gene unlinked to the MHC controls expression of HLA class II genes

Class II (or Ia) antigens are highly polymorphic surface molecules which are essential for the cellular interactions involved in the immune response. In man, these antigens are encoded by a complex multigene family which is located in the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and which comprises up to 12 distinct alpha- and beta-chain genes, coding for the HLA-DR, -DQ and -DP antigens. One form of congenital severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) in man, which is generally lethal, is characterized by an absence of HLA-DR histocompatibility antigens on peripheral blood lymphocytes (HLA class II-deficient SCID). In these patients, as reported here, we have observed an absence of messenger RNA for the alpha- and beta-chains of HLA-DR, -DQ and -DP, indicating a global defect in the expression of all class II genes. Moreover, the lack of expression of HLA class II mRNAs could not be corrected by gamma-interferon, an inducer of class II gene expression in normal cells. Family studies have established that the genetic defect does not segregate with the MHC. We conclude, therefore, that the expression of the entire family of class II genes is normally controlled by a trans-acting class II regulatory gene which is unlinked to the MHC and which is affected in the patients. This gene controls a function or a product necessary for the action of gamma-interferon on class II genes.     

Suppressor T cells control the HLA-linked low responsiveness to streptococcal antigen in man

We have previously reported that low immune responsiveness to the streptococcal cell wall (SCW) antigen is controlled by an HLA-linked dominant gene which we designated as an immune suppression gene to the SCW antigen (Is-SCW) without knowing its function. We have extended the study of the genetic control of the immune response to the SCW antigen and confirmed both the bimodal distribution of immune responsiveness and HLA-linked dominant inheritance of low responsiveness. Here we report an analysis of the function and expression of Is-SCW at the cellular level and demonstrate that the Is-SCW controls the generation of antigen-specific suppressor T cell in low responders.     

Structural polymorphism of I-E subregion antigens determined by a gene in the H-2K to I-B genetic interval

THE generation of immune responses in mice is influenced by Ir genes located in the I region of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC)(1). In some instances maximum responses require complementation by two genes, one in the I-A or I-B and the other in the I-E or I-C subregion(2,3). The effects of these genes are thought to be mediated by Ia alloantigens, which are cell surface molecules whose expression is controlled by the I region(4). This is based on the observations that anti-Ia sera inhibit in vitro immune responses(5,6), and soluble factors that enhance in vitro immune responses express Ia alloantigenic determinants(7,9). Jones et al.(10), using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, observed that the expression of I-E subregion antigens is controlled by two genes, one in the I-A subregion, the other in the I-E subregion, and that the polymorphism of these antigens is influenced by an I-A subregion gene. As an explanation, the authors proposed that only one of the two polypeptide chains present in I-E immunoprecipitates is an I-E subregion product, the second being a product of the I-A subregion. Antisera obtained by cross-immunisation of I-E subregion-disparate strains of mice immunoprecipitates a molecular complex consisting of two chains, designated alpha and beta, with molecular weights of 32,000 and 29,000 respectively(11-14). Previous studies suggested that I-E antigens isolated from B10.A(5R) and B10.D2 mice had identical alpha-chains but different (beta)-chains(15). However, as these mice differed at multiple genetic regions, it was not possible to show which I subregion(s) determined the polymorphism of the E(beta) chain. Therefore, we investigated the effects of the I-A subregion on the polymorphism of I-E subregion antigens. We have now shown by peptide mapping that the I-E subregion polymorphism which Jones et al. found to be controlled by the I-A subregion probably reflects structural polymorphism of beta-chains controlled by an I-A subregion gene.     

Abolition of specific immune response defect by immunization with dendritic cells

Murine cytotoxic T (Tc)-cell responses to various antigens are controlled by immune response (Ir) genes mapping in the major histocompatibility complex (H-2). The genes responsible are those encoding the class I and class II H-2 antigens. The H-2 I-Ab mutant mouse strain bm12 differs from its strain of origin, C57BL/6 (H-2b), only in three amino acids in the I-A beta bm12 class II H-2 molecule. As a consequence, female bm12 mice are Tc-cell nonresponders to the male antigen H-Y and do not reject H-Y disparate skin grafts. We now report that bm12 mice generate strong H-Y-specific Tc cells following priming in vivo and restimulation in vitro with male bm12 dendritic cells (DC). Female bm12 mice primed with male DC also reject male skin grafts. Furthermore, we demonstrate that only responder cell populations containing a mixture of L3T4+ (T-helper (Th) phenotype) and Lyt 2+ (Tc phenotype) T lymphocytes generate H-Y-specific Tc cells. These data imply an essential role for Th cells, activated by DC as antigen-presenting cells (APC), in changing H-Y-nonresponder bm12 mice into H-Y responders. Priming and restimulation with DC allows the triggering of a T-cell repertoire not demonstrable by the usual modes of immunization. This principle might be used to overcome other specific immune response defects.     

High risk of squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix for women with HLA-DQw3

Many immune responses are controlled by genes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). In man these include the loci encoding the HLA-A, -B, -C, -DR, -DQ and -DP antigens, and many diseases have been linked with these. But attempts to identify HLA genes in man that might explain why an immune response against malignant tumours should be ineffective have so far been disappointing, apart from the association reported between the HLA-DR1 antigen and a susceptibility to a rare carcinoma of the thyroid gland. Here we describe another strong connection between a common malignant tumour and an HLA antigen, namely between HLA-DQw3 and squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix: from the 1988 United States tumour registry, 1 in every 63 newborn girls will develop this invasive cancer. We found that 88% of 66 patients had the leukocyte antigen HLA-DQw3 when it would normally be expected in only 50% of individuals. In animals the immune system and the MHC act in defence against virally induced tumours, but until now there has been no evidence that they do so in humans: as squamous cell carcinoma is probably virally induced, our discovery of its association with an HLA antigen will be important to the understanding of the immunogenetic basis of a susceptibility to this tumour.     

Predominant use of a V alpha gene segment in mouse T-cell receptors for cytochrome c

The T-cell receptor is a cell surface heterodimer consisting of an alpha and a beta chain that binds foreign antigen in the context of a cell surface molecule encoded by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), thus restricting the T-cell response to the surface of antigen presenting cells. The variable (V) domain of the receptor binds antigen and MHC molecules and is composed of distinct regions encoded by separate gene elements--variable (V alpha and V beta), diversity (D beta) and joining (J alpha and J beta)--rearranged and joined during T-cell differentiation to generate contiguous V alpha and V beta genes. T-helper cells, which facilitate T and B cell responses, bind antigen in the context of a class II MHC molecule. The helper T-cell response to cytochrome c in mice is a well-defined model for studying the T-cell response to restricted antigen and MHC determinants. Only mice expressing certain class II molecules can respond to this antigen (Ek alpha Ek beta, Ek alpha Eb beta, Ev alpha Ev beta and Ek alpha Es beta). Most T cells appear to recognize the C-terminal peptide of cytochrome c (residues 81-104 in pigeon cytochrome c). We have raised helper T cells to pigeon cytochrome c or its C-terminal peptide analogues in four different MHC congenic strains of mice encoding each of the four responding class II molecules. We have isolated and sequenced seven V alpha genes and six V beta genes and analysed seven additional helper T cells by Northern blot to compare the structure of the V alpha and V beta gene segments with their antigen and MHC specificities. We have added five examples taken from the literature. These data show that a single V alpha gene segment is responsible for a large part of the response of mice to cytochrome c but there is no simple correlation of MHC restriction with gene segment use.     

Identical V beta T-cell receptor genes used in alloreactive cytotoxic and antigen plus I-A specific helper T cells

T lymphocytes involved in the cellular immune response carry cell-surface receptors responsible for antigen and self recognition. This T-cell receptor molecule is a heterodimeric protein consisting of disulphide-linked alpha- and beta-chains with variable (V) and constant (C) regions. Several complementary DNA and genomic DNA clones have been isolated and characterized. These analyses showed that the genomic arrangement and rearrangement of T-cell receptor genes using VT, diversity (DT), joining (JT) and CT gene segments is very similar to the structure of the known immunoglobulin genes. We have isolated two cDNA clones from an allospecific cytotoxic T cell, one of which shows a productive V beta-J beta-C beta 1 rearrangement without an intervening D beta segment. This V beta gene segment is identical to the V beta gene expressed in a helper T-cell clone specific for chicken red blood cells and H-21. The other clone carries the C beta 2 gene of the T-cell receptor, but the C beta 2 sequence is preceded by a DNA sequence that does not show any similarity to V beta or J beta sequences.     

Binding of immunogenic peptides to Ia histocompatibility molecules

Most cellular interactions essential for the development of an immune response involve the membrane glycoproteins encoded in the major histocompatibility gene complex. The products of the I region, the class II histocompatibility molecules (Ia molecules), are essential for accessory cells such as macrophages to present polypeptide antigens to helper T cells. This interaction, antigen presentation, is needed for T-cell recognition of the antigen and its consequent activation. How the Ia molecules regulate the immune response during antigen presentation is not known, although it is commonly thought to result from their association with the presented antigen. Recent studies, including the elucidation of the structure of the T-cell receptor, favour recognition of a single structure, an antigen-Ia complex. Here we report attempts to determine whether purified Ia glycoproteins have an affinity for polypeptide antigens presented by intact cells in an Ia-restricted manner. We first identified the epitope of a peptide antigen involved in presentation. Several laboratories have shown that globular proteins are altered (processed) in intracellular vesicles of the antigen-presenting cell before antigen presentation. A major component of the T-cell response is directed toward determinants found in the unfolded or denatured molecule, and our laboratory has shown that the determinant of the hen-egg lysozyme protein (HEL), presented in H-2k mice to T cells, is a sequence of only 10 amino acids. This portion resides in an area of the native molecule partially buried inside the molecule, in a beta-sheet conformation. To be presented, intact or native HEL must first be processed in acidic intracellular vesicles. Having isolated the peptide responsible for T-cell recognition of HEL, we sought a physical association of this peptide with purified, detergent-solubilized I-Ak molecules from B-hybridoma cells. We have found such an association, which may explain the role of the Ia glycoproteins in cellular interactions.     

Unresponsiveness to a foreign antigen can be caused by self-tolerance

In mice, two sets of genes govern the immune response to the synthetic antigen GT. One maps to the major histocompatibility complex and behaves like a typical immune response gene. The second is a background gene encoding a cell surface structure found on B cells. Mice which express, and are therefore tolerant of, one form of this structure do not respond to GT. Thus, tolerance of self generates holes in the T-cell repertoire, partially crippling the immune system.     

Cotransfection of ICAM-1 and HLA-DR reconstitutes human antigen-presenting cell function in mouse L cells

The initiation of a specific immune response is believed to require not only activation through antigen-specific receptors on T cells and B cells but also antigen-independent interactions between accessory molecules. One such molecule is LFA-1, which enhances the avidity of interactions between T cells and antigen-presenting cells, and is possibly involved in signal transduction across the T-cell membrane. Intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1), a surface glycoprotein of relative molecular mass (Mr) 80,000-110,000, has been defined as a ligand for LFA-1, and has been shown to participate in the interaction between T cells and monocytes. The determination of the precise contribution of such accessory molecules to antigen presentation, however, is complicated by the need to analyse against a background of multiple molecular interactions. We have investigated the role of LFA-1/ICAM-1 interactions in antigen presentation directly by quantifying the contribution of ICAM-1 expression to T-cell stimulation using L-cell transfectants that co-express ICAM-1 and HLA-DR. In the case of transfectants expressing modest levels of HLA-DR, co-expression of ICAM-1 is critical for effective HLA class II-restricted and allospecific T-cell activation, pointing to an important role for ICAM-1 in the induction of T-cell responses.     

Functional interaction between human T-cell protein CD4 and the major histocompatibility complex HLA-DR antigen

Mature T cells segregate phenotypically into one of two classes: those that express the surface glycoprotein CD4, and those that express the glycoprotein CD8. The CD4 molecule is expressed primarily on helper T cells whereas CD8 is found on cytotoxic and suppressor cells. A more stringent association exists, however, between these T-cell subsets and the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene products recognized by their T-cell receptors (TCRs). CD8+ lymphocytes interact with targets expressing class I MHC gene products, whereas CD4+ cells interact with class II MHC-bearing targets. To explain this association, it has been proposed that these 'accessory' molecules bind to monomorphic regions of the MHC proteins on the target cell, CD4 to class II and CD8 to class I products. This binding could hold the T cell and its target together, thus improving the probability of the formation of the trimolecular antigen: MHC: TCR complex. Because the TCR on CD4+ cells binds antigen in association with class II MHC, it has been difficult to design experiments to detect the association of CD4 with a class II molecule. To address this issue, we devised a xenogeneic system in which human CD4 complementary DNA was transfected into the murine CD4-, CD8- T-cell hybridoma 3DT-52.5.8, the TCR of which recognizes the murine class I molecule H-2Dd. The murine H-2Dd-bearing target cell line, P815, was cotransfected with human class II HLA-DR alpha, beta and invariant chain cDNAs. Co-culture of the parental T-cell and P815 lines, or of one parental and one transfected line resulted in a low baseline response. In contrast, a substantial increase in response was observed when CD4+ 3DT-52.5.8 cells were co-cultured with HLA-DR+ P815 cells. This result strongly indicates that CD4:HLA-DR binding occurs in this system and that this interaction augments T-cell activation.     

Expression and function of CD4 in a murine T-cell hybridoma

The CD4 (T4) antigen was originally described as a phenotypic marker specific for helper T cells, and has recently been shown to be the receptor for the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Functional studies using monoclonal antibodies directed at CD4 and major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules led to the suggestion that CD4 binds to the MHC class II molecules expressed on stimulator cells, enhancing T-cell responsiveness by increasing the avidity of T cell-stimulator cell interaction and/or by transmitting a positive intracellular signal. But recent evidence that antibodies to CD4 inhibit T-cell responsiveness in the absence of any putative ligand for CD4 has been interpreted as suggesting that antibody-mediated inhibition may involve the transmission of a negative signal via the CD4 molecule instead. We have infected a murine T-cell hybridoma that produces interleukin 2 (IL-2) in response to human class II HLA-DR antigens with a retroviral vector containing CD4 cDNA. The resulting CD4-expressing hybridoma cell lines produce 6- to 20-fold more IL-2 in response to HLA-DR antigens than control cell lines. Furthermore, when antigen levels are suboptimal, the response of the cell lines is entirely CD4-dependent. The data presented here clearly demonstrate that CD4 can enhance T-cell responsiveness and may be crucial in the response to suboptimal levels of antigen.     

Functional epistasis on a common MHC haplotype associated with multiple sclerosis

Genes in the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) encode proteins important in activating antigen-specific immune responses. Alleles at adjacent MHC loci are often in strong linkage disequilibrium; however, little is known about the mechanisms responsible for this linkage disequilibrium. Here we report that the human MHC HLA-DR2 haplotype, which predisposes to multiple sclerosis, shows more extensive linkage disequilibrium than other common caucasian HLA haplotypes in the DR region and thus seems likely to have been maintained through positive selection. Characterization of two multiple-sclerosis-associated HLA-DR alleles at separate loci by a functional assay in humanized mice indicates that the linkage disequilibrium between the two alleles may be due to a functional epistatic interaction, whereby one allele modifies the T-cell response activated by the second allele through activation-induced cell death. This functional epistasis is associated with a milder form of multiple-sclerosis-like disease. Such epistatic interaction might prove to be an important general mechanism for modifying exuberant immune responses that are deleterious to the host and could also help to explain the strong linkage disequilibrium in this and perhaps other HLA haplotypes.     

XIAP deficiency in humans causes an X-linked lymphoproliferative syndrome

The homeostasis of the immune response requires tight regulation of the proliferation and apoptosis of activated lymphocytes. In humans, defects in immune homeostasis result in lymphoproliferation disorders including autoimmunity, haemophagocytic lymphohystiocytosis and lymphomas. The X-linked lymphoproliferative syndrome (XLP) is a rare, inherited immunodeficiency that is characterized by lymphohystiocytosis, hypogammaglobulinaemia and lymphomas, and that usually develops in response to infection with Epstein-Barr virus (EBV). Mutations in the signalling lymphocyte activation molecule (SLAM)-associated protein SAP, a signalling adaptor molecule, underlie 60% of cases of familial XLP. Here, we identify mutations in the gene that encodes the X-linked inhibitor-of-apoptosis XIAP (also termed BIRC4) in patients with XLP from three families without mutations in SAP. These mutations lead to defective expression of XIAP. We show that apoptosis of lymphocytes from XIAP-deficient patients is enhanced in response to various stimuli including the T-cell antigen receptor (TCR)-CD3 complex, the death receptor CD95 (also termed Fas or Apo-1) and the TNF-associated apoptosis-inducing ligand receptor (TRAIL-R). We also found that XIAP-deficient patients, like SAP-deficient patients, have low numbers of natural killer T-lymphocytes (NKT cells), indicating that XIAP is required for the survival and/or differentiation of NKT cells. The observation that XIAP-deficiency and SAP-deficiency are both associated with a defect in NKT cells strengthens the hypothesis that NKT cells have a key role in the immune response to EBV. Furthermore, by identifying an XLP immunodeficiency that is caused by mutations in XIAP, we show that XIAP is a potent regulator of lymphocyte homeostasis in vivo.     

Construction, expression and recognition of an H-2 molecule lacking its carboxyl terminus

A mouse major histocompatibility antigen (H-2) gene, encoding a novel H-2Ld molecule lacking its intracytoplasmic domain, has been constructed and introduced into mouse L-cells. The novel H-2 molecule is found on the surface of the transfected cells at the same level as L-cells transfected with the native H-2Ld gene. Allo- and influenza-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes can recognize the truncated H-2 gene product nearly as efficiently as the normal H-2Ld gene product. However, vesicular stomatitis virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes recognize the truncated H-2Ld molecule less efficiently than the complete H-2Ld product. The rate of capping of the truncated H-2Ld molecule was investigated and found to be the same as that of the complete H-2Ld gene product.